Step 1: Pause and gather what you know
Before any conversation, list what you actually have: the assignment rules as stated, the work itself, any drafts, and anything specific that concerned you. Separate observations ("three sources I cannot find") from impressions ("it sounds like AI"). A hunch is not a finding. If a detector score is part of the picture, remember it is not proof; see Do AI detectors work?
Step 2: Talk with the student privately
Choose a calm moment and a private setting. Ask the student to walk you through how they made the work. Questions work better than statements.
Example opening:
- "I would like to understand how you worked on this assignment. Can you walk me through how you got started and what you did next?"
- "I noticed a few things I had questions about, like the sources in the third paragraph. Can you tell me where they came from?"
- "If a tool helped at any point, I want to hear about it. I would rather understand what happened than guess."
Listen fully before responding. Let the student explain without interruption.
Step 3: Separate confusion from hiding
Some students misread unclear rules, believed a small use (such as rewording a sentence) was fine, or did not know they had to say so. Others knew the rule and tried to conceal what they did. The two situations call for different responses. Honest confusion is mainly a teaching moment. Deliberate hiding is more serious and may need a firmer response.
Step 4: Respond with learning first
A first response should be educational. Options include:
- Redoing the task, or part of it, in class or with a process trail.
- A short written reflection on what happened and what the student will do differently.
- A clear restatement of expectations for the next task.
- Practice documenting any permitted AI use.
Students who honestly declare permitted use should not be penalized for doing so.
Step 5: Escalate through your school's process
If the concern is serious or repeated, follow your school's existing academic integrity practices. Involve administration and families as your school's process requires, and ask your administrator if you are unsure what applies. Consequences, where they apply, should come from that process and not from one teacher's judgment alone. See AI and academic integrity and What should a school AI policy include?
Step 6: Document factually
Write down what you observed, what the student said, what was agreed, and the date. Stick to facts and avoid guesses about motive. Short, neutral notes protect both you and the student.
Step 7: Check your own rules
Ask whether the task rules were clear. Did students know if AI could be used for brainstorming, editing or drafting? Was the rule written down? A rules problem is a teacher problem too, and fixing it prevents repeat cases. If the rules were vague, say so to the student, clarify them for the whole class, and write them on the next handout. Naming this openly models the honesty you hope to see from students. For how misuse differs from copying, see Plagiarism vs. unauthorized AI use.
Quick answers
Should I give a zero right away?
A first response should be educational, and consequences should follow your school's academic integrity process. Talk with the student and consult your administrator before deciding.